Getting Lost in Thoughtspace; Sitting on a Hill


Tell Me About Your Maze

I hope you’re always trying to grow. Most people are, I think — I know I am. But it’s easy to deceive yourself into thinking you’re making progress. I remember a time in high school where I devoted much of my free time to epistemological pursuits I felt were of the utmost importance, only to look back a year later and realize I had been hamster wheeling myself. If I had to analogize the process of doing ontology refinement (I use this term somewhat interchangeably with the notion of epistemological pursuits), I would compare it to finding your way around a non-Euclidean high-dimensional maze, trying to construct a mental map of the space (wink wink).1 It’s definitely possible to make progress, and frequent reflection on where you’ve been can yield some insights into the structure of the space. But it’s hard to predict where you’re going, most progress comes from experimentation rather than inference, and it’s easy to walk in loops without even noticing.2 There are definitely a few ways the maze model falls short — local maximums, for example — and these could be ironed out were they the focus of this essay. But I mention the maze only to provide a very clear example of the difficulty of meta-epistemology.

The end goal of your reflection doesn’t really matter. For most ends, you have to figure everything else out along the way. So many things affect the process by which thoughts develop. To understand anything as perfectly as possible, it is necessary to understand the limitations of language, cultural frameworks, various ways of thinking (and in which contexts you apply each, their benefits and drawbacks, their lenses, etc.). The list goes on, both with things I am aware of and with those I am as of yet not. And of course a revelation in any of these areas requires a reassessment of the rest, as the thinking that produced your current understanding is often now outdated. In this way, differing ontological pursuits gradually become meta-ontological pursuits, and then epistemological pursuits, with the minutiae of the original ontology often being lost along the way.3 I do not think this is a bad thing. If anything, the mathematician in me finds beauty in the abstraction. But I do think most epistemological essays focus on putting forth an idea from a context. This has value — these act as ontological snapshots, as waypoints for the weary traveller of thought space to rest at before continuing on their journey. I just wish more attention was put towards the study of the space itself, of the ways in which the context determines the claim, of the paths in thoughtspace, of the experience of being a traveller. I wish people did more meta-epistemology.

I said earlier that meta-epistemology was hard. I don’t think it’s intractable. Our mazes may differ, but they’re probably homeomorphic. It is precisely by discussing the ways in which the maze is nonsensical that we begin to understand it.

Take a Moment on the Hill

I worry that the prelude to my thesis (what I have written thus far) outshines the ideas I originally intended to present. I will share them nonetheless — they are my first step towards discussion of the maze.

It is not always best to change as fast as possible, to charge bullishly ahead towards progress — in doing so, one becomes a slave to their axioms. One quickly becomes trapped in a local maximum. Of course, it is often not bad to be in a local maximum — this is precisely what makes them dangerous. But it’s important to know when you’re in one. It’s easy to pursue minutiae without realizing it, and miss the forest for the trees. I was once a utilitarian — I thought deeply about eugenics, and produced many interesting arguments on the topic from the framework I was embedded in. But now that I am no longer a utilitarian, these arguments provide little value. You should assume you are at the half-life of your beliefs. If you have actively considered an idea for ten hours (or 5000 words — perhaps a better measure), assume after another ten hours of thought you will no longer hold it. This is arbitrary (and a little stupid), but the epistemological approach it imposes strikes me as mostly correct.

Be sure to understand your assumptions, and spend more time challenging them than building off of them. Know what you believe (but forget once in a while — noise is good). And take your time. You don’t know the escape distance of your local maximum. In a dogged march through thoughtspace, you can only see ahead of you. But as you sit on a hill and catch your breath, the fog clears, and slowly, you can begin to see around you. Gaze down the path you’ve walked; notice its patterns. Gaze ahead, and see the path curves back around. Perhaps you’ve been walking in loops this whole time. Maybe, just maybe, if you sit for long enough, far in the distance a new path will reveal itself. It will soon be time to get up, stretch your legs, and return to the march. Before you do, take a moment; tell me what you see. I have sat for a year, and I hope to tell you what I have seen — I hope you will return the favor.

Now it is time for a march through the fog.


← All Inktober entries

1. In some sense this is less an analogy, and more a literal description — this is probably the first step to how I would actually attempt to model ontological refinement. ↩
2. I don’t want to clog the essay with examples, but I will add a nice one down here: another way to think about this maze is as a mystery function from an unknown space to $\mathbb{R}$, where all you see is the output. The image I have in mind for loops is a multi-valued complex operation circling around the origin, seemingly giving different outputs, but making no progress. ↩
3. This is a hard statement to make, as “epistemology” and “ontology” are both often used in a variety of ways. I am also guilty of this. What I’m trying to say here is that often specific questions necessarily beget more and more abstract ones — the process of diving deeply into a simple question, regardless of the question itself, is often the process of deeply understanding the way minds process ideas. Someone investigating how art is perceived, someone grappling with religion, and someone attempting to model the inner workings of their friend might all find themselves asking the same questions. The statement “ontology becomes epistemology,” then, is actually claiming that upon close inspection, much of the semi-epistemological facets of ontologies share a common abstract epistemological basis. ↩