Simplest Structures


Go in Life

I played a lot of board games as a kid — it was a part of my familial culture. I’m half decent at chess, and I promise you I can put up a good fight in Terraforming Mars. But rather than in depth, I think most of what I’ve learned lies in breadth; I can play a decent game of just about anything on my first try. Most modern strategy games have hidden numbers they’re balanced around — they can be reduced to resource conversion ratios, limiting factors, etc. They’re all just optimization problems.

This perspective did not help me learn Go. There’s not much to optimize; the required approach, though tactical, lies more in the realm of patience, clarity, etc. But in working to improve, despite the stylistic differences, I found myself learning new things about my usual genre of game. Go, in its simplicity, forces failure patterns to the surface: over the course of only a few dozen games, a tendency to greedily overextend and get punished emerged. And indeed, regardless of the game, I tend to focus on my loss-conditions and undervalue my win chances when ahead, causing me to take unnecessary risks (I do this in real life too, actually).

This post obviously isn’t about Go. Rather, Go serves as a concrete example of how stripping away the complexity of a structure (e.g. board games) allows for an investigation of one’s failure modes. Similarly, running is the simplest type of exercise — in pursuing it, mental limiting factors make themselves apparent. A thesis and a question emerge. First, it’s important to recognize the simplest form of whatever you pursue. In simply doing so, you allow realizations to generalize (extending this, it’s worth categorizing activities to allow discoveries to transfer). But this begs the question: we spend a lot of time living, existing, being sentient, etc. What’s the simplest form of that? What facets of existence generalize most broadly across life? Which ones betray your flaws most explicitly?

I’m inclined to say Go again, and I don’t think I would be particularly wrong. But this isn’t really the answer I’m looking for. Go is what you get when you take board games and strip away all the artificial complexity. So take life and strip away all the… all the what? I’m not sure. The simple answer is the Go of life is being alone, not having anything to do, etc. But it’s not the case that happiness (if this is even a useful metric) here correlates that strongly with happiness when busy. Certainly, I wouldn’t say a human’s default state is alone. I do think there are some meaningful takeaways there. But it doesn’t strike me as the “correct” answer, if such a thing exists. It doesn’t feel satisfying. It’s also possible humans just don’t have some sort of nice default state like what I’m looking for. But this seems to overspecify the scope of my search a bit; I don’t find it particularly satisfying either. I’d be curious to hear what you think.


← All Inktober entries